March 2016 - What fantasy books are you reading?

Silvion Night

Sir Readalot
Staff member
I finally finished The Complete Fiction by H.P. Lovecraft. The title explains why this one took me so long: the book contains literally every novel, short story and poem written by the great master of surreal Horror (1200 pages, small print, big pages). As @Alucard mentioned before, these books are not really meant to be read back to back, it rather is a coffee-table book which is best enjoyed when being read over a long period of time. However, I was interested to see how Lovecraft's style would develop over the years (the stories are in chronological order), and I wasn't disappointed by the effect this had. It was a very interesting and highly entertaining read (although I've had my fill of the words "eldritch" "paleontologean" and any word which starts with un-, such as "unspeakable").

Some stories were definitely better than others. The ones that stood out to me were the novellas At the Mountains of Madness, the Call of Cthulhu, the Dunwich Horror, the Thing on the Doorstep, The Shadow out of Time and The Colour out of Space.

Recurring themes are hereditary degradation, forbidden knowledge and something what I would call the Cosmological Insignificance of Man (and racism. Seriously, this guy was a real racist, and not only viewed from our time. I bet he was seen as such in his own time as well. Non-Caucasian races are invariably depicted as malignant, dumb and evil).

The stories can be divided into 3 general strata:

1. Those taking place in and around Arkham/Kingsport/Innsmouth. These are fictional places in New England where the supernatural lurks around every corner. Expect zombie-, vampire- and witch-stories.
2. Those taking place in the dream-world (which is invariably very close to the real world and intermingling between worlds takes place constantly).
3. The cosmological tales, which take place all around the world/universe and involve the Elder Races, Ancient Gods, the Great Ones etc (the Cthulhu Mythos is part of this for example).

The red line through all these stories is the idea that the supernatural is all around us. Human kind is just one of the many races which inhabit our planet. Many more powerful (sometimes alien) races live in our world/universe. Gods walk the earth Malazan-style and are ready to devour the unwary/unlucky person who comes seeking for forbidden knowledge and thereby stumble across things he shouldn't have. Cthulhu, Nyarlathotep, Azathoth, the mad poet Abdul Alhazred (author of the dreaded Necronomicon) are baddies who play a role in almost every Lovecraft story.

I am loathe to give this book a rating, as it is a story-bundle and as such the style and quality varies mightily from story to story. Suffice it to say that the book is awesome and that I can recommend it to anyone who wants to learn more about the history of horror/fantasy/surrealism and is not squeamish about exciting horror tales.

My next project will be to read Anthony Ryan's Raven Shadow trilogy of which Blood Song is the first book.


Journeyed there and back again
My next project will be to read Anthony Ryan's Raven Shadow trilogy of which Blood Song is the first book.
Will be interested in your thoughts. First book was outstanding. Second book was really good BUT you have to accept the fact the author changed the format from a single perspective (Blood Song) to multiple POVs in book two. Some people couldn't handle the sharing of the story and it bothered them. After re-reading the first two books before the final one I appreciated the second book more. And then you must set the bar really low for the final book (just check Goodreads to see the falling review scores).

There are so many minor characters during this series that it is best read altogether and not over a long period of time.

Maark Abbott

Journeyed there and back again
@TomTB and @Silvion Night thank you both.

Yep finally finished MBoTF, definitely an excellent series and one that I was sad to have reached the end of but also glad that I had gone through it all due to the amount of time reading it all.

I enjoyed the ending and felt that it came to a good conclusion.
You have gone through the crucible and emerged ascendant. Welcome to the family.


Journeyed there and back again
March already and I have read one book (technically though it could be zero, as I had started it at the end of last year).

I have branched out too reading comics instead, I will be honest and I thought I wouldn't enjoy them, but I have been pleasantly surprised.

I be making my way back to a 'proper' book after my latest comic, and I have over a thousand threads to catch up on on here at some point !

And who do I speak to about the theft of all my credits ?
Welcome back! I've been wondering what happened to you. I suppose you need an easy breather after Malazan! :cool:


In the name of the Pizza Lord. Charge!
Staff member
@Silvion Night
I agree with Rudy, it's best if you read Raven's Shadow books consecutively. It's one of the rare series I have done so with, and I think the payoff was really good.
Unlike Rudy though, I was fully on board with Ryan's vision. I really like this series (my overall rating was 8.8/10, with 9/9/8.5 for the 3 books respectively). I'm looking forward to his new series from which the 1st book is due this year.

Here are the threads for each book if you wanna discuss them.


Journeyed there and back again
Yesterday I've spent three hours in Milan's Stazione Centrale, due to the umpteenth strike of the rail workers, amidst a measureless and unruly crowd, that at the 50-something cancelled train tried to storm the gates and lynch the bastards. In a corner, seraphic as fucks, me and a few kindred spirits sat leisurely on a wall, drinking beer after beer, each reading his own book - including a frail looking granny reading, with evident delight, Cook's Torre di Tenebra (Tower of Fear) - a woman after my own heart ;)

Anyway, finished Cameron's The Dread Wyrm, in spite of a few minor quibbles
the Blanche romance;
Nita Qwan, the most useless POV ever;
the lack of details on what's happening in the Empire and in Arelat
and the death of a couple of minor characters I was strongly rooting for, another brilliant instalment in this series, probably even the best one. And Cameron in my opinion is definitely the fantasy author who writes the most realistic and engaging fighting scenes, both for individual duels, both for large scale battles.

Now reading Kearney's Hawkwood's Voyage


Journeyed there and back again
I had read the preview of Heroes Die and found it overly violent to an extreme level. I didn't feel like reading the whole book. Does it continue to be extremely violent throughout the book?
Yes, it's wonderful.

Maark Abbott

Journeyed there and back again

Sir Arthur

Journeyed there and back again
Cugel: The Skybreak Spatterlight. I'm a big fan of Jack Vance, but I wasn't blown away by the first two Dying Earth books. This third book however, is a better example of what I've come to expect from Jack Vance. Whimsical, hilarious, and extremely well written. Of course, it was written much later in his career. The early 80's.Around the time he wrote the Lyonesse trilogy one of my all time favorite fantasy tales.


Super Moderator
Staff member
15% into The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern. It's ok up to this point, nothing overly special so far though.


Journeyed there and back again
@moonspawn will be happy to know that after a brief hiatus I have picked up "The Narrator" by Michael Cisco once again. I have to say that this is one of the better "war novels" I have read even though it is considered "weird fantasy" if there is such a classification.


Journeyed there and back again
Finished Kearney's Hawkwood's Voyage, what an amazing and unforgiving book, wondrously bleak and bloody, but never gratuitously so. Memorable and quite realistic battles, werevolves, sea voyages, political maneuvering, it definitely seems the start of something glorious.

Let's see if The Heretic Kings is on par